Are Gutter Screens Worse than Gutter Cleaning?

Published 02/10/22

Cleaning your gutters isn’t easy! It’s a big job, a messy job, and can be a dangerous job. And if you aren’t up to doing it for yourself, it can also be an expensive job. So it’s understandable that homeowners would look for ways to reduce or eliminate their need to clean the gutters in the first place. Various products can be installed on home gutters meant to eliminate the need for gutter cleaning, but some are better than others. Gutter screens, for example, may not be everything they’re cracked up to be.

Moving The Debris

gutter screen.
Gutter screens can sound good, but can they really do what you need?

The idea behind gutter screens is that they’re supposed to allow rainwater through without allowing debris to get into the gutters and clog them up. And if the screens are working correctly, they will do that. But there’s a problem.

The thing is, the gutter screens simply lay over the gutter openings. This means that the debris may not be able to get into the gutter, but it may get stuck on top of the screen. And if you have enough debris covering the screen, the rainwater can’t get into the gutters in the first place. So, for the screens to continue working, someone will have to clean them off periodically. That could be easier than cleaning out the gutters, but it may not be – it still requires accessing a high point of the house, after all, and the debris may not necessarily be easy to remove.

Wear and Breakage

No matter how well screens work when they’re first installed, you can’t count on them remaining whole and undamaged forever. Screens are useful, but they’re not the hardiest objects around. You’ve probably noticed holes forming in your screen window coverings or screen doors – the same thing can happen to your gutter screens. 

These screens are, after all, exposed to the elements regularly. Harsh weather may weaken the material, and there’s no guarantee that a sharp stick or other pointed debris won’t poke into it. Various pests, like birds and rats, also try to find their way into gutters for shelter, and they can bite or damage screens. And once there are holes in the screens, you have an opening that may allow larger debris through – however, most models don’t easily allow you to open them or access the inside of the gutters to clean them. This could make clogging issues worse instead of better. 

Poor Installation or Weak Seals

Gutter installer.
A gutter professional may be able to give your home gutters the protection that you’re looking for.

Gutter screens are some of the most inexpensive and easy-to-install gutter guards, making them a common DIY solution. Unfortunately, that also means that it’s easy to install them incorrectly. And even if you don’t, the mechanism by which they stay attached to the gutters may not be strong.

These screens can become detached when you aren’t expecting it due to poor installation or weak attachments. Also, if a high wind blows your screen off the gutter, you have no protection against whatever else that wind might blow into the gutter.

Ultimately, gutter screens really don’t replace regular gutter cleaning, and if you use them, they’ll require regular cleaning themselves. If you’re looking for gutter cleaning, or if you want a gutter guard solution that’s more effective and durable than gutter screens, Harry Helmet can help. They’ve been working on roofs and gutters like yours for over three decades, and they have solutions that can really lighten your workload and give you peace of mind.  Schedule a free estimate.

Schedule a free estimate.

45th Anniversary Sale
25% OFF*
+ 0% Same as Cash up to 18 Months † | Ends 8/31/26
By checking I accept, I acknowledge that it serves as my E-Sign ACT signature, and I expressly consent to having Lednor Corporation (Lednor Home Solutions) contact me via phone or text about products or sales promotions. This includes contact even if my number is on a state or national Do Not Call Registry. I understand these calls or texts may use an automatic telephone dialing system or prerecorded messages to the number provided above. Standard message and data rates may apply. I can reply STOP at any time to opt out. I also understand that this consent is not required to obtain any goods or services, I can call 888-543-5638 instead. I have reviewed and agree to Terms | Privacy Policy

REVIEWS

1 Million+ Satisfied Customers Nationwide

Working with the team at Lednor was a pleasure, from Rich in sales to all follow-up. Our gutter installation was quick, and the new gutters and helmets look amazing. Very professional company!
StarStarStarStarStar
I installed GH on the upper gutters in 2006 & have had the wonderful experience of no problems. I installed Leaf Filter on the lower gutters in 2010. Thru time, grit & leaves collect on the gutter screens & semi-annual cleaning is necessary so water doesn’t overrun the screens. I’m replacing LF w/ GH. GH is as advertised - maintenance-free!!
StarStarStarStarStar
Lednor recently installed a rolling sun shade on my house. The entire process went very smoothly and I would recommend them and their product to anyone. The salesperson was very professional and was able to answer all my questions. The installers were likewise very good. The job was done in about 2-1/2 hours and they did a very good job cleaning up after themselves. The sunshade is wonderful. I can use my patio in the middle of the day now which I hadn't been able to do. I highly recommend them.
StarStarStarStarStar
I am very satisfied with my gutter helmet installation. They were here when they said they would be. Work was timely completed and looks great. Installers were very nice and cleaned everything up. The house looks great. The best part - I do not have to clean them out.
StarStarStarStarStar
Everyone was great…from the home show to the sales rep to the installers. Very professional. Absolutely love my awning. Would highly recommend.
StarStarStarStarStar
Awesome experience in every way! Extremely professional and friendly, experienced staff! Awning is amazing!
StarStarStarStarStar

$650 OFF*

We work hard with each manufacturer to offer our customers the best promotions monthly.

Find a Location

Serving a Location Near You

Careers

Join the Lednor Home Solutions Family

We're seeking fun, outgoing, and confident individuals who enjoy winning to join our team. Lednor Home Solutions is an equal opportunity employer and we operate a safety first & drug-free workplace focused on employee safety. Great pay and benefits, apply today!