Should You Choose Roof Repair Over Replacement?

Roof repair
Do you need a new roof or a roof repair? 

How do you know if you need a new roof or a roof repair? A repair can be less expensive than replacing your entire roof, but will it actually work? Make sure that you’re not repairing your roof year after year. Choose to repair when sensible, replace when necessary, and support your roof with structures that allow you to maintain it easily.

What Caused the Damage?

According to Bob Vila, “Torn or damaged shingles can be removed, and new ones can be slipped in place” relatively easily if you’ve lost a few shingles due to a branch falling on the house or a powerful windstorm. Small roofing issues on a newer roof don’t generally merit a roof replacement, unless that branch that fell through the house was actually a big part of the tree.

Do You Mind the Aesthetics? 

If you have a newer roof or you were forward-thinking and saved some shingles from your past roofing project, you could find a match when you patch your roof. Otherwise, you will likely have a section of your roof that looks a little different from the other parts. This is not necessarily a reason to change your entire roof, but if you find that your roof is starting to look like a patchwork quilt, this could be one reason to add to your list of justifications for actually replacing the roof.

Can You Re-roof Halfway? 

If there is a lot of damage to the roof or you don’t really like the look of a large roof repair, you can also consider partial reroofing. For instance, if a tree branch hits the back of your house, you could add new roofing on the back and keep the old on the front. This gives you the benefits of a consistent look and age of roofing on each side.

Roof repair
Has your roof seen better days? 

Will Your Patches Hold? 

Have you ever patched a beloved pair of jeans, only to discover that your patches fall off because they’e attached to fraying fabric? If you’re repairing your roof, you need to make sure that you’re not patching on top of material that will not hold. For instance, if your asphalt shingles are aging and falling apart, patching them may work for a short time, but if your entire roof is crumbling, it’s more sensible and realistic to look at a roof replacement. 

Consider the Life Expectancy of Your Roof 

If you’re thinking about adding a few more patches, think about the life expectancy of your roof before you move forward. According to Home Advisor, “If old age has taken its toll on your entire roof, replacement is the obvious choice.” This can be expensive, but if you find yourself constantly patching the roof, it can ultimately be less expensive than repairing your roof each year.

How Are You Supporting Your Roof? 

When you’re evaluating whether or not to put a new roof on your home, you need to look at the systemic causes of your roof problems. For example, if the structures underlying your roof are damaged, rotting, or sagging, you may need to conduct larger-scale repairs. If water has pooled on your roof and is moving into your attic, that is a sign of a larger problem that requires much more than a tiny repair. If your gutters are leaking or backing up onto the roof, repairing the roof won’t fix that problem. If your roof is full of systemic issues such as sags, leaks, and poor drainage, it may take more than a small roof repair to solve your roofing woes.

At Harry Helmet, we want you to feel comfortable in your home. That means that your home should have no leaky roof, no sagging gutters, and no worries about erosion around your home. If you’re considering roof repair or replacement, talk with us. We’ll help you make the decision that’s best for your home. Schedule a free estimate today.

Written by Del Thebaud

Spring Sale!
18% OFF
+ no money down, no interest, no payments for 1 Year† | Hurry, Offer Ends 4/30/2024
I authorize Lednor Home Solutions to contact me about our products via phone, email, or text. You also understand we use an autodialing phone system, and my consent is not required to obtain a free estimate - I can call 888-543-5638 instead. We will never share your personal information with 3rd parties for marketing purposes or spam you. You can opt out at any time. Message/data rates apply. Consent is not a condition of purchase. Terms | Privacy Policy


1 Million+ Satisfied Customers Nationwide

I recently had the Gutter Helmet by Harry Helmet installed on my house. It not only looks amazing, but the guys arrived on time, were professional and efficiently got the job done. I am very satisfied with Gutter Helmet's attention to detail and fulfilling their work as promised. I will definitely tell my neighbors about the Gutter Helmet.
I have had Gutter Helmets for 20 years. In all that time I've never had a problem until recently a bird's nest found its way into one of my gutters. The installer who came to replace the product was the same installer from 20 years earlier. Now that's impressive. Everyone at Gutter Helmet inclusive of the office staff were professional and a pleasure to work with.
Gutter Helmet by Harry Helmet just replaced our roof and we could not be more satisfied. The crew showed up early, worked all day and stayed late, were professional and caring regarding the project and the surrounding impact it had on our property and home. They completed the roof quickly and it looks simply amazing!
VERY happy with our entire experience adding Gutter Helmet by Harry Helmet to our house. Installing this was a great value for us. The gutters are working perfectly in heavy downpours and with year-long leaves and debris coming down from our river birches. Terrific customer service and a first class product.
We needed our roof repaired due to wind damage. After several quotes, Gutter Helmet was the only company that went into our attic to look and see if more damage had occurred. If it wasn't for them taking the extra time to look at everything, we would have had rotting wood under our new roof. They were very professional and gave a fair quote.
We just had Gutter Helmet installed on our gutters and couldn't be happier. They provided us with useful information about Gutter Helmet and cleaned up everything, leaving no mess behind. We definitely recommend Gutter Helmet to anyone considering this product.

18% OFF

We work hard with each manufacturer to offer our customers the best promotions monthly.

Find a Location

Serving a Location Near You


Join the Lednor Home Solutions Family

We're seeking fun, outgoing, and confident individuals who enjoy winning to join our team. Lednor Home Solutions is an equal opportunity employer and we operate a safety first & drug-free workplace focused on employee safety. Great pay and benefits, apply today!