Should You Repair or Replace a Shingled Roof?

Americans are faced with “fix the old one or buy a new one” decisions all the time. Should you repair your lawnmower, or just go purchase a new model? Should you try to augment or improve your old computer, or just invest in the latest model? Should you tell the heating contractor to fix your current unit, or install a new one? And should you take your old car to the mechanic to be fixed, or the auto dealership to trade in for another one?

Along those lines, homeowners often face the dilemma of whether to repair their roof or pay out a large sum of money to have it replaced. While the answer depends on the individual situation (much like the examples alluded to above), here are some guidelines that can help you make this difficult decision:

It’s probably best to repair your current roof if:

    • You’ve got a deadline to meet. If you have company arriving soon or are getting ready to go on a trip, it may be tough to schedule a roofer to replace your entire roof on short notice.
    • Your roof isn’t that old. In most cases, a roof that’s 15 years old or less should last you quite a bit longer.
    • The problem area is small. If the shingles are broken or missing in a single area or two, those can be easily fixed.
    • The cost of a roof replacement would be substantially more than repairing the current problem on your shingled roof.
    • Your roof only has a single layer of shingles on it. In many cases, it’s just as effective (and cheaper) to put another layer of shingles over the spot that needs repair.
    • Differences in shingle color aren’t a big deal, like if the part of the roof to be fixed faces the back yard or is obscured by trees.
    • There is no underlying moisture damage. If your roof deck, underlayer, and support beams are still intact, then shingling over the problem area will likely be sufficient.

You should probably opt for a roof replacement if:

    • You have some time in your schedule. You’ll need the time to seek out a qualified contractor, get on his schedule, and have all the work completed.
    • Your roof is old. If you have a roof that is over two decades old, you may start to see additional problems – so you should think about replacing it altogether.
    • There are large and/or multiple areas that need to be fixed. This is another sign that the quality of the entire roof may be deteriorating.
    • The additional cost of a roof replacement is less than the cost of repairing it. For instance, if a roof repair would cost $5,000 and a new roof would cost an extra $3,500, it’s probably a better investment to replace the entire roof.
    • You have two layers of shingles on your roof. Most building codes prohibit more than two layers, meaning that repair would involve ripping off old shingles (which would cost more than shingling over it).
    • It’s important that your roof remain a uniform color. If the problem area faces the street, or you plan to sell your home soon, a new roof adds to your residence’s curb appeal.
    • You have underlying moisture damage. A roof replacement involves installing a new roof deck and removing moisture-damaged areas of your entire roof.

If you choose to get your roof fixed, be sure to get a firm cost estimate from the contractor before you start. If a roof replacement is the better option, contact Harry Helmet at 1-888-5-HELMET for a free in-home inspection and estimate. Harry Helmet uses only the highest-quality materials, backs up its work with a full workmanship warranty, and assigns a dedicated project manager to your home.

Written by Del Thebaud

Anniversary Sale
25% OFF
+ no money down, no interest for one year† | Hurry, Offer Ends 7/31/2024
I authorize Lednor Home Solutions to contact me about our products via phone, email, or text. You also understand we use an autodialing phone system, and my consent is not required to obtain a free estimate - I can call 888-543-5638 instead. We will never share your personal information with 3rd parties for marketing purposes or spam you. You can opt out at any time. Message/data rates apply. Consent is not a condition of purchase. Terms | Privacy Policy


1 Million+ Satisfied Customers Nationwide

I recently had the Gutter Helmet by Harry Helmet installed on my house. It not only looks amazing, but the guys arrived on time, were professional and efficiently got the job done. I am very satisfied with Gutter Helmet's attention to detail and fulfilling their work as promised. I will definitely tell my neighbors about the Gutter Helmet.
I have had Gutter Helmets for 20 years. In all that time I've never had a problem until recently a bird's nest found its way into one of my gutters. The installer who came to replace the product was the same installer from 20 years earlier. Now that's impressive. Everyone at Gutter Helmet inclusive of the office staff were professional and a pleasure to work with.
Gutter Helmet by Harry Helmet just replaced our roof and we could not be more satisfied. The crew showed up early, worked all day and stayed late, were professional and caring regarding the project and the surrounding impact it had on our property and home. They completed the roof quickly and it looks simply amazing!
VERY happy with our entire experience adding Gutter Helmet by Harry Helmet to our house. Installing this was a great value for us. The gutters are working perfectly in heavy downpours and with year-long leaves and debris coming down from our river birches. Terrific customer service and a first class product.
We needed our roof repaired due to wind damage. After several quotes, Gutter Helmet was the only company that went into our attic to look and see if more damage had occurred. If it wasn't for them taking the extra time to look at everything, we would have had rotting wood under our new roof. They were very professional and gave a fair quote.
We just had Gutter Helmet installed on our gutters and couldn't be happier. They provided us with useful information about Gutter Helmet and cleaned up everything, leaving no mess behind. We definitely recommend Gutter Helmet to anyone considering this product.

Save 25% OFF

We work hard with each manufacturer to offer our customers the best promotions monthly.

Find a Location

Serving a Location Near You


Join the Lednor Home Solutions Family

We're seeking fun, outgoing, and confident individuals who enjoy winning to join our team. Lednor Home Solutions is an equal opportunity employer and we operate a safety first & drug-free workplace focused on employee safety. Great pay and benefits, apply today!